A Comparison of the Efficacy of Modafinil and Dextroamphetamine as Alertness Promoting Agents in Aviators Performing Extended Operations

http://www.usaarl.army.mil/TechReports/2011-05.pdf
USAARL 2011-05


A Comparison of the Efficacy of Modafinil and Dextroamphetamine as Alertness Promoting Agents in Aviators Performing Extended Operations

Arthur Estrada, Amanda M. Kelley, Catherine M. Webb, Jeremy R. Athy, John S. Crowley, Lana S. Milam, Steven J. Gaydos, Heber D. Jones, Melody R. King, Bradley S. Erickson, Jim A. Chiaramonte, Stephanie M. Moon, Robert S. MacNeill, John G. Ramiccio, Patricia A. Leduc

Successful military operations depend on maintaining continuous day-night operations. Stimulants are easy to use and popular for sustaining performance because their utility is not dependent on environmental or scheduling modifications. Eighteen pilots each completed 15 helicopter flights and other evaluations during two 40 hr periods of sustained wakefulness during which they received 2 of 3 experimental conditions: 3 doses at 4 hr intervals of modafinil (100mg), dextroamphetamine (5mg), or placebo. Statistical results showed that the stimulants maintained alertness, feelings of well-being, cognitive function, judgment, risk perception, and situation awareness of sleep-deprived aviators consistently better than placebo and without side effects of aeromedical concern. Like previous research, this study strongly suggests that these drugs can maintain acceptable levels of mood and performance during sleep deprivation. The results also confirm that modafinil is well tolerated and appears to be a good alternative to dextroampheatmine for countering the debilitating mood and cognitive effects of sleep loss during sustained operations.

modafinil, dextroamphetamine, stimulants, extended wakefulness, sustained operations, fatigue